top of page

Childfree Guilt: "Am I a Bad Person for This?"

Nov 10
6 min read

Featuring an excerpt from Valentine Blue


There's a question I hear from women in our community more than almost any other. It doesn't always come out in those exact words. Sometimes it shows up as a joke at brunch. Sometimes it's a long, late-night support seeking message in the group.


Sometimes it's just a quiet "does anyone else feel this way?"


The question is: Is something wrong with me because I don't want kids?


When my friend Valentine Blue, a certified sex coach and the founder of OddBird, sent me a piece she'd written about this exact feeling, I had to stop what I was doing. It's honest in a way that's rare. She doesn't wrap it in a bow or pretend the guilt isn't there. She just says it.


With her permission and written in collaboration: here's how it begins:

No, I don't want a child. No, I won't regret it. That's the first thought that landed, clear and complete, somewhere between the buffet and the kids' pool. I was on holiday, in a hotel full of families with young children. The sound volume stayed high and high-pitched through lunch and dinner. Most activities evolved around families, and the attention of every adult is placed on entertaining children. I watched the whole scene from a lounge chair, my journal in one hand, a Martini Blanco in the other, and realised with an impressive clarity: I don't want anyone else to come before me. I want to remain the center of my own world. Am I a bad person for this?
The past two months, I've found those questions surfacing again, uninvited but inevitable. Do I want a child, someday? Why does every woman around me seem to love kids when I couldn't care less about them? Does that make me a bad person? A heartless, selfish, eternally bitter bitch who doesn't know what she is talking about, until she does? What if I never do want a child? What if becoming a mother would be the least interesting thing I could ever do with my life?
I still feel guilty for thinking that. I wonder if other women do too. I know some do, that I'm not alone in this, and yet I still feel alone in it.

Why that last line got me


The Single and Childfree Network

"I know I'm not alone in this, and yet I still feel alone in it."


That sentence is the whole reason the Single & Childfree Network exists.


There are millions of us. We're not a fringe group or a phase. And still, so many women carry this decision like a secret. We know, logically, that other women feel the same. But knowing it in your head and feeling it in your body are two different things. You can read the statistics and still be the only one at the table who gets the look when you say, "No, I don't have kids, and I'm not planning to."


For a long time, I had friends who would say things to me like, “You'll never know real love,” or “You don't understand what being tired really means because you're not a mom.” And that made me question my own wholeness: What didn't I understand? Am I not complete as a woman without kids? Did I want this? Could I live without it? And that discernment was very powerful for me.


Honestly, not only have I never felt that pull toward motherhood, I was constantly questioning it because it was not a hard "FUCK YES" calling to me. I also never found myself in a relationship where I felt safe and secure enough to want to bring a child into the world. There wasn't one defining moment when I knew. It was a collection of observations, conversations, and experiences. Watching women struggle, seeing how motherhood could limit their mobility, opportunities, independence, and career trajectories, and witnessing the ways so many women sacrificed parts of themselves. I saw it, I understood it, and I simply didn't want that life for myself. But even when I was comfortable with my decision, there was still this feeling that I was somehow different or that I needed to explain myself.


That really started to change when I created this community. I realized I wasn't the only one. There were thousands of women who understood exactly what I meant, who had heard the same comments, experienced the same judgment, and quietly wondered if they were the only ones who felt this way. And there's something incredibly powerful about going from knowing intellectually that other women exist to actually feeling that solidarity and having it be something accesible in your everyday life. Having a space where I don't have to explain or defend my choices, where my life is understood without a disclaimer, has healed a part of me I didn't even realize needed healing. I'm proud of my choices, comfortable in my life, and no longer feel like I'm standing alone at that table.


No matter how many times people have said the nasty, degrading things, and no matter how much they have said we are selfish...I stand proud that being "selfish" is a byproduct tool of self-knowing.

Childfree Guilt: Let's talk about the word "selfish"


Valentine names the fear so many of us have: that wanting to stay the center of your own world makes you selfish, heartless or bitter. Here's my take: choosing a life you actually want isn't selfish. It's honest.


What would be selfish is bringing a child into the world out of pressure, guilt or fear of missing out. What would be selfish is pretending to want something just to make other people comfortable.


We've been taught that a woman's value is measured by how much of herself she gives away. So when a woman says, "I want my time, my energy and my life to be mine," it can feel like breaking a rule. It's not. It's knowing yourself.

And being the center of your own world doesn't mean you love less. The SINKs I know are the friends who show up, the aunties who spoil, the mentors, the caretakers, the community builders. We pour into people all the time. We just get to choose how. And sometimes, even with that knowing, we can still feel shame and guilt for being happy with our choices.


It's just that everything around us is so unsupportive of that choice and the lack of representation is real. Plus, often times, those around us, the water carriers, patriarchy all subliminally tell us that we are not enough, wrong, and we are not doing our duties as women. It is a rub that burns...


The childfree guilt is real, and it doesn't mean you're wrong

I want to be clear: feeling guilty doesn't mean you made the wrong choice. Guilt is often just the gap between what you know about yourself and what you were told you should want.


That gap takes time to close. For a lot of us, it never fully goes away. It gets loud at baby showers, at weddings, at the holidays, when someone asks, "So when are you going to settle down?" for the hundredth time.


What helps isn't pretending the guilt isn't there. It's having people around you who get it, so you're not carrying it alone.


Read Valentine's full piece on her Substack → HERE

The Single and Childfree Network

Before the holidays hit


We're heading into the season of family tables, pity invites and loaded questions, and I know that's when the "am I enough as I am?" feeling hits hardest. That's why I'm so excited that Valentine is bringing her new workshop, Enough, to our community first.


Enough: A Workshop for Single, Solo & Childfree Women - Sunday, December 13 · 3pm ET / 12pm PT · Live on Zoom for SCF Network members


Enough is a live self-intimacy workshop for women who are tired of proving their lives are complete. You'll find where your energy leaks into pleasing and performing, and leave with practices to feel full on your own terms.We'll talk about why it's harder than ever for our generation to feel like enough, what "enough" actually looks like, and how to build a full, connected, intimate life on your own terms. Think of it as a reset before the holiday chaos.


Not a member yet? Join the Single & Childfree Network to save your seat, and to find a whole community of women who get it.

Angela Gentile is the founder of The Single and Childfree Network, a global community connecting single and childfree women through friendship, shared experiences, and meaningful connection. As an community builder, entrepreneur, podcast host, and speaker, Angela advocates for greater visibility and representation of for single and childfree women building fulfilling lives outside traditional relationship and family structures.


Guest feature: Valentine Blue, known as the Solo Sex Coach, is a certified sex coach, self-intimacy mentor, writer, and founder of OddBird. After a decade working in sexual health, harm reduction and advocacy across Europe, she now helps solo and unconventional adults build intimacy from the inside out through her Intimacy Ecosystem framework. She writes The OddBird Letters on Substack about erotic psychology, self-knowledge and relationships beyond couplehood.


Interested in partnering or collaborating? For brand partnerships, speaking engagements, media inquiries, and collaborations, contact Angela at partnerships@theangelagentile.com


Looking for your people? Join The Single and Childfree Network and connect with women who get it, wherever you are in the world. Join the Network

Comments


bottom of page